Annulment of Administrative Fines Regarding Bearer Share Certificates: Review of the Constitutional Court Decision
Introduction
Law No. 7262 dated 27.12.2020 introduced an obligation to notify the Central Registry Agency (“CRA”) regarding the issuance and transfer of bearer shares under the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (“TCC”) and stipulates that those who violate the notification requirement under Art. 486/2 of the TCC shall be subject to an administrative fine of TRY 20,000 and those who fail to notify in accordance with Art. 489/1 of the TCC shall be subject to an administrative fine of TRY 5,000. With its decision dated 18.01.2024 and numbered E. 2021/28 and K. 2024/11[1], the Constitutional Court resolved to cancel the 13th paragraph added to Art. 562 of the TCC, the administrative fine of TRY 5,000 has been annulled. Below, the new regulation on bearer shares and the annulled sanction will be assessed within the Constitutional Court’s decision.
Regulations Regarding Bearer Shares
As per Art. 489 of the TCC as amended by Law No. 7262, the enforcement of the rights arising from the shareholding of the holders of bearer share certificates against the company and third parties is conditioned upon the notification of such shareholding to the CRA. The condition of being the holder of a bearer share certificate, which was the rule for bearer share certificates before the amendment, is no longer sufficient by itself, and the holder of a bearer share certificate cannot exercise his/her rights unless the CRA is notified. In addition, the date of notification to the CRA is taken as a basis for asserting the rights attached to the bearer share certificate against the company and third parties.[2]
Under the new regulation, the transfer of bearer share certificates of joint stock companies is also subject to the notification requirement to the CRA. While before the amendment, only the transfer of possession was sufficient for the transfer of bearer share certificates, under Art. 489 of the TCC, the transferee may not exercise its rights attached to the shares unless the transfer is notified to the CRA. The date of notification to the CRA shall be taken as the basis for the exercise of the rights attached to the shares.[3]
Under the amendment to Art. 486 of the TCC, companies issuing new bearer share certificates must notify the CRA of these newly issued certificates. Accordingly, companies may only distribute the relevant share certificates to shareholders following the notification to the CRA. Failure to make such notification would result in an administrative fine of TRY 5,000 under Art. 562/13 of the TCC, which is annulled by the Constitutional Court.
As per the amendment made to Art. 426/2 of the TCC, the person who proves that he/she is has a bearer share certificate and who is notified to the CRA is authorized to exercise the rights arising from share ownership against the company. Therefore, the holder of a bearer share certificate who can participate and vote in the general assembly of the company will also be the person who is registered in the CRA records. In parallel, under Art. 417 of the TCC and Art. 6 of the Communiqué on Notification and Registration of Bearer Share Certificates to the Central Registry Agency (“Communiqué”)[4] , the schedule of shareholders provided by the CRA shall be taken into consideration in the preparation of the list of attendees for the recorded bearer share certificates.
As per Art. 11 of the Communiqué, records regarding bearer shareholders and the shares they hold will be kept in the electronic environment created by CRA. The records and notifications can be made electronically by accessing the CRA system via e-Government Gateway (E-Devlet Kapısı) with an electronic signature, e-government password or the Turkish Republic Identity Card number or by logging in directly from CRA’s application called “e-Investor: Investor Information Center” (e-Yatırımcı Bilgi Merkezi).
As per Art. 12 of the Communiqué, companies, and shareholders of bearer shares are obliged to notify the CRA of any changes in the contact information they previously provided. The relevant company or shareholder is responsible for keeping the contact information up-to-date.
The Communiqué also includes regulations on the realization of measures and lien to be applied to bearer shares and regulations on the notification of minors, incapacitated persons, and heirs to CRA.
Constitutional Court’s Annulment Decision
The lawsuit filed before the Constitutional Court requested the annulment of the administrative fine to be imposed in case of violation of the notification obligation introduced by subparagraph (b) of paragraph (13) added to Art. 562 of the TCC by Art. 33 of the Law on the Prevention of Financing the Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction dated 7.12.2020 and numbered 7262, because the rule is contrary to Art. 38 of the Constitution, since the act subject to administrative fine is not regulated in a precise and foreseeable manner in the law and leaving this issue to the regulation would not be compatible with the principle of legality in crime.
The legal assessment of the unconstitutionality made by the Constitutional Court can be summarized as follows;
- The first paragraph of Art. 38 of the Constitution states that “No one shall be punished for an act which the law in force at the time it was committed does not criminalize; no one shall be punished with a heavier penalty than the penalty prescribed for that offense in the law at the time he committed the offense”, thus guaranteeing the legality of the crime; In the third paragraph, it is stated that the principle of legality of punishment is guaranteed by stating that “Punishment and security measures substituting for punishment can only be imposed by law” and it is emphasized that following the principle of legality in crime and punishment, prohibited acts and the punishments to be imposed for these prohibited acts must be clearly, comprehensibly and discretely in the law, leaving no room for any doubt.
- The Constitutional Court assessed that the principle of legality in crime and punishment can be considered a special regulation of the rule that fundamental rights and freedoms expressed in Article 13 of the Constitution can only be restricted by law. It emphasized that it is not sufficient for regulations regarding crime and punishment to be enacted formally in the form of law. Instead, the act subject to criminal sanction must be criminalized by law, and legal rules must be precise, accessible, and foreseeable in a way that does not allow for arbitrariness. In this respect, it is declared that the texts of the laws should be written in such a way that individuals can foresee with a certain clarity and certainty which legal sanction or consequence is attached to which concrete act and fact, and that individuals should know with a certainty that which legal sanction is attached to which act in the law and that the consequences of the actions should be foreseeable.
Again in the Decision it is concluded that;
- Since Art. 38 of the Constitution does not distinguish between administrative offenses and penalties and judicial offenses and penalties, both are subject to the same principles; in judicial and administrative offenses, there is a violation of a legal value protected by the legislator with an act that violates the norms of behavior and constitutes an injustice, and both judicial and administrative penalties involve coercion (CC, E.2015/85, K.2016/3, 13/1/2016, §13);
- The main difference between administrative offenses and penalties and judicial offenses and penalties is that the legal value protected and the legal consequences caused by the violation are not the same; although there are also regulations that allow administrative fines to be imposed in amounts higher than judicial fines, since the penalties foreseen for judicial offenses are generally more severe than the penalties for administrative offenses, since the penalties that bind freedom are generally valid for judicial offenses, since administrative offenses involve the violation of a legal value to which the legislator attributes less importance, and since the sanction prescribed is generally imposed by an administrative authority following administrative procedures, Art. 38 of the Constitution does not to administrative offenses and penalties. The principle of legality in crime and punishment should be applied more flexibly in terms of administrative offenses, taking into account the slow functioning of the legislative body and the rapidly changing and developing conditions of economic and technical life (CC, E.2015/85, K.2016/3, 13/1/2016, § 14; E.2019/110, K.2021/85, 11/11/2021, § 19);
- In this context, as stated in the preamble of Art. 38 of the Constitution, although the principle of legality in crime and punishment does not prevent the legislator from establishing explicit criminal provisions, for an administrative offense and punishment to be considered by Art. 38 of the Constitution, the subject matter of the offense and its sanction must be clearly stated in the law in a way that leaves no room for doubt;
- It is clear that the rule stipulating the imposition of administrative fines for misdemeanors is a provision of law in formal terms and is accessible. However, it was concluded that while the specified rule considers the act of failing to notify under Article 489 (1) of the TCC as a crime and prescribes the imposition of an administrative fine for this act, neither the rule nor the referenced article includes a provision regarding the time frame within which the notification must be made. Therefore, it is unclear within what time frame the failure to notify the transfer of bearer share certificates to the CRA would constitute the commission of the misdemeanor.
It was concluded that the elements of the crime prescribed in the rule are not regulated by law and that the rule does not meet the legality requirement, and therefore it was decided that it should be annulled.
Conclusion
As a result of the annulment decision of the Constitutional Court, the regulations regarding the obligation of joint stock companies issuing new bearer share certificates to notify the CRA of the newly issued certificates and the distribution of the relevant share certificates to the shareholders only after such notification remain valid, but the administrative fine to be imposed in case of failure to make such notification has been annulled. It would be appropriate for the legislator to introduce a new regulation regarding the time period within which the notification to the CRA must be made to impose an administrative fine.
- Official Gazette dated 03.04.2024 and numbered 32509, https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/03.04.2024 (Constitutional Court Decision).
- Gökdemir, Tamer: “Hamiline Yazılı Pay Senetleri İçin 7262 Sayılı Kanun İle getirilen Değişiklikler ve Hukuki Sonuçları”", Prof. Dr. H. Ercüment Erdem'e Armağan, Volume I, İstanbul 2023, p.701.
- Gökdemir, Tamer, p.702.
- Official Gazette dated 06.04.2021 and numbered 31446: https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/06.04.2021.
All rights of this article are reserved. This article may not be used, reproduced, copied, published, distributed, or otherwise disseminated without quotation or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm's written consent. Any content created without citing the resource or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm’s written consent is regularly tracked, and legal action will be taken in case of violation.
Other Contents
Under Article 365 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 ("TCC"), each member of the board of directors, which is the body responsible for the administration and representation of a joint stock company, is obliged to fulfill their duties arising from the law and the articles of association within the limits...
Similar to previous years, in 2024, mergers and acquisitions (“M&A”) transactions continue to be shaped by global economic dynamics, geopolitical risks and technological innovations...
The common goal (in the ideal world) of people who become shareholders by participating in the capital of a company or managers by participating in the management body is to manage the company in the best way and to obtain maximum economic benefit...
The most common forms of agency agreements can be categorized under three main headings. These can be listed as an Agency Agreement, Distributorship Agreement, and Franchise Agreement...
Employee shareholding, which means the ownership of some or all of the capital of a publicly traded or closed company by employees, has attracted great interest in many countries around the world, particularly in the United States of America, due to the advantages it provides to the national economy, the...
There are many different rules that newly established companies must consider and comply with when starting their commercial activities. One of these rules is the "Evasion of Law" article regulated under Article 356 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 ("TCC"). The relevant rule aims to prevent the...
The Turkish automobile and light commercial vehicle market left the 2000s behind with steadily rising sales figures and the 2010s with high and stable sales figures as well. In this period, the growth of the market was driven not only by high purchase power but also by easy access to credit and product diversity...
Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 ("TCC") provides the right to exit from the company to the shareholders of limited liability companies and the right to squeeze out the shareholder from the company, unlike the structure of joint stock companies, with the exit and squeeze out institutions specially regulated for...
Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (“TCC”) preserves the rule that the board of directors shall manage and represent joint stock companies. The TCC regulates how the power of representation shall be exercised, the registration and announcement of the persons authorized to represent, the transfer of the...
Ordinary partnerships are regulated under Turkish Law between Articles 620 and 645 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (“TCO” or the “Code”). The Law defines an ordinary partnership contract as a contract where two or more persons undertake to combine their labour or property to achieve a common...
Merger and acquisition processes are one of the legal processes that most seriously affect the identities and legal status of companies. After the completion of legal, tax, financial and operational due diligence reports, the parties initiate the negotiation process in case they reach an agreement on proceeding with the...
A popular business model for expanding market reach and brand recognition worldwide is franchising. Despite being less common than distribution agreements in the form of mono-brand store agreements, franchising is another significant method for extending luxury brands' distribution networks. Luxury brands use...
In the decision dated 14.06.2022 and numbered 2019/149 E. 2022/894 K., the Court of Cassation General Assembly (“CCGA”) evaluated the theory of piercing the corporate veil in the context of the relationship between the guarantor and the borrowing company in a dispute arising from a loan agreement...
The European Union continues to be an important investment center for foreign investors. According to data from the European Commission's "Second Annual Report on the monitoring of foreign direct investment in the European Union", the European Union received €117 billion worth of foreign direct investment in...
Transfer of shares is arguably the first legal transaction that comes to mind among the legal transactions regarding the shares of a capital company, and the most common transaction in practice. However, the shares of a capital company may also be subject to various transactions, other than share purchase...
Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce (E-commerce Law or Law) has recently undergone a radical change in order to regulate the behavior of the players in the rapidly growing and developing e-commerce sector. The new regulations that came into force as of January 1, 2023 envisage important...
On 11 June 2021, the German Federal Parliament approved the German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (Lieferkettensorgfaltsgesetz) (“Act”) which affects not only German entities but also their suppliers in foreign countries (including Turkish entities). The main focus of the Act, which entered into force on...
On 21 December 2007, the Federal Council approved the draft revision of the Swiss Code of Obligations, which also includes amendments to company law. On 28 November 2014, the Federal Council referred the draft revision for consultation. Following extensive discussions and a long enactment process, the...
The Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 ("TCC") regulates maritime trade contracts under the fourth part of the fifth book of the Code. Among the types of contracts regulated in this section, the most frequently used contract in international maritime transport practice is the freight contract regulated under...
Prohibition on hidden income shifting is one of the most important issues that is broadly regulated under Capital Markets Law No. 6362 (“CML”). In conjunction with CML Article 21, which has a broader context than Article 15 of the abrogated Capital Markets Law No. 2499, another significant step has been taken...
As a result of developing commercial activities and large-scale investments, especially concluded in the fields of construction, energy and mining, companies are seeking to participate in these investments by uniting their powers and expertise to take advantage of financial opportunities together. This tendency...
The Turkish Commercial Code (“TCC” or “Law”) has enabled companies to apply different structural models and to implement new legal formations by including spin-off provisions to its Article 159 et seq. In accordance with the provisions of the law, companies may transfer a certain element, or elements, of their...
The International Federation of Consulting Engineers is a professional association established in 1913, known as the FIDIC (Fédération Internationale Des Ingénieurs-Counseils). Its members are duly elected from consultant-engineer associations of various countries, and membership to the association is...
Incoterms are a set of rules introduced by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) to explain the commercial terms that are widely used in international trade. The purpose of Incoterms rules is to facilitate and expedite international trade in a safe and secure manner...
The regulation applicable to all Turkish ports prepared by the Ministry of Transport, Maritime Affairs and Communications that entered into force after being published in the official gazette on October 31, 2012 (˝the Regulation˝), consolidates all the bylaws, regulations and instructions in a single Regulation...
As a rule, rights and obligations arising from an agreement have legal consequences only between the creditor and the debtor which are parties to the agreement. This principle is referred to as "privity of contract." In general, contracts for the benefit of third parties, where the fulfillment of an...
The rules of e-commerce, which grow and develop with the digitalizing world, are changing. E-commerce has become the driving force of the digital economy. However, considering the growth rate of e-commerce and the transformation it has undergone in a short time, it is obvious that some...
The dissolution of a company is a specific type of dissolution, which results in the cancellation of the legal personality which was gained by registration at incorporation. The specific proceeding which leads to the dissolution, and thus, the termination of a company upon the constitutive decision...
Companies in which shares or authority to manage is held by members of a family are considered to be “family businesses”. Family members can hold shares that control the company, as well as retain management authority. Having a family business means opportunity, security and income for...
Turkey ratified the Convention on the Contract for International Carriage of Goods by Road (“CMR”) in accordance with Act No. 3939 dated 7 December 1993, and the CMR entered into force in Turkey on 31 October 1995. In accordance with Article 1 / 1 of the CMR, the carriage of goods by road...
Ordinary partnerships are governed by Article 620 et seq. of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (“TCO”). An ordinary partnership agreement is defined as an agreement whereby two or more persons undertake to join efforts and/or goods to reach a common goal...
The concept of disguised profit transfer in joint stock companies, in its broadest meaning, covers the transfer of company assets to related parties and may occur in different ways. This concept is regulated in detail under capital markets legislation...
Share subscription agreements, which are commonly encountered in start-up investments, set out the terms and conditions of an investor’s participation in a company as a shareholder by subscribing the new shares issued in a capital increase...
The electronic signature, which has the same legal consequences as wet signatures if it meets certain conditions, has taken its place in many legal systems and has enhanced commercial life. Although there are various types and applications in different legal systems...
INCOTERMS are a set of rules introduced by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) to explain the commercial terms that are widely used in international trade. The purpose of the Incoterms rules is to contribute to and facilitate the safe and swift conduct of international trade...