Confidentiality of Written Communications between Lawyer and Client In Accordance With Dow Decision
Introduction
Certain information and documents obtained during the investigations of the Competition Board (“Board”) may be based on the lawyer-client relationship. The extent of the information and documents based on a lawyer-client relationship protected within the framework of confidentiality principle is important. The Board’s decision dated 02.12.2015 and numbered 15-42/690-259 (“Dow Decision”)[1] with regard to whether or not some of the documents taken during on-the-spot inspections are considered within the scope of the confidentiality of written communications between lawyer and client is handled under this newsletter article.
Request for Information and On-the-Spot Inspection in Competition Law Practice
As per Art. 14 of the Act on the Protection of Competition No. 4054 (“Act No. 4054”), in carrying out the duties assigned to the Board by this Act, the Board may request any information it deems necessary from all public institutions and organizations, undertakings, and associations of undertakings. Officials of these authorities, undertakings, and associations of undertakings are obliged to provide the requested information within the period to be determined by the Board.
Pursuant to Art. 15 of Act No. 4054, in carrying out the duties assigned to the Board by this Act, the Board may perform examinations at undertakings, and associations of undertakings, in cases where it is deemed necessary. To this end, it is entitled to: (i) examine the books, any paperwork and documents of undertakings, and associations of undertakings, and make copies of the same if needed, (ii) request written or oral statements on particular issues, and (iii) perform examinations on the spot with regard to any assets of undertakings. Those concerned are obliged to provide the copies of information, documents, books and other instruments as requested.
Information and Documents Obtained Within the Scope of Dow Investigation
Certain information and documents obtained during the investigations of the Board may be the based on the lawyer-client relationship. As per the Board’s decision dated 10.11.2015 and numbered 15-40/667-M, it has been decided to open an investigation with respect to whether Dow Türkiye has infringed Art. 6 of the Act No. 4054. During the on-the spot inspection, the return of some of the documents that were taken when on-the-spot inspection was conducted as per Art. 15 of the Act No. 4054 has been requested since they were within the scope of confidentiality of written communications between lawyer and client.
As stated in the Board’s Dow Decision, “The principle of confidentiality (principle of legal professional privilege) prohibits the forced disclosure of information provided by the enterprises or persons to their lawyers and written communications made between them when receiving legal consultancy services and protect this communication. This protection aims to release the persons’ -who receives consultancy- concerns about the forced disclosure of the information and written communications that are obtained, and direct them to provide all the information that they have in their possession to their lawyers, and to exercise their rights of defence in a real sense. Therefore, the lawyers would implicitly be able to defend their clients that they represent, effectively. Additionally, this protection is in conflict with persons’ obligations to reveal all of the information on the dispute, and it otherwise contradicts truth being achieved through justice. Thus, it should be generally accepted that the limit of protection granted to such written communications must fit the purpose.”
“Pursuant to the said principle, the written communications made between an independent lawyer who is not bound to the client by a relationship of employment, for the purposes, and in the interests of the client's rights of defence, are deemed to be professional written communications, and may benefit from the protection. This protection covers the written communications made with the independent lawyer for the purpose of exercising the client’s right of defense, as well as the document that is prepared with regard to receiving consultancy services from the independent lawyer. However, written communications that are irrelevant to exercising the client’s right of defense, with the intention to infringe upon, or to hide an ongoing infringement, or a future infringement, shall not benefit from the protection even if they are related to the preliminary investigation, investigation or inspection. Within this framework, for instance, legal advice of an independent lawyer provided to an enterprise with regard to whether or not an agreement infringes Act No. 4054 benefits from such protection; whereas, correspondence concerning the manner in which Act No. 4054 may be infringed upon shall not benefit therefrom.”
The confidentiality principle stated in the Dow Decision is discussed in the Board’s decision[2] dated 20.08.2014 and numbered 09-14-29/596-262, as well. The said decision states that “Granting legal protection to written communications made between the lawyer and the client is one of the guarantees of the right to defense and, therefore, it is often accepted as privileged in the legal arena. However, there are different applications in relation to the nature and scope of protection.”
Moreover, the AM&S Europe Ltd. v. Commission case[3] of the Court of Justice of the European Communities (“CJEC”) is addressed in decision numbered 14-29/596-262. In the said case, as per the CJEC, the confidentiality of written communications between lawyer and client are subject to two conditions. With regard to the first condition, written communications between lawyer and client must ensure that the rights of the defence may be preserved to the fullest extent. With respect to the second condition, such written communications must be made with an ‘independent’ lawyer who is not bound to the client by a relationship of employment.
Protection and Confidentiality of Information and Documents based on the Professional Relationship between Lawyer and Client under the Turkish Legal System
There are certain regulations under the Turkish legal system with respect to the protection and confidentiality of information and documents based on the professional relationship between lawyer and client. One of these is introduced by Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271 (“Code No. 5271”). Pursuant to Art. 130/2 of Code No. 5271, “If the attorney, whose office is searched, or the president of Bar, or the attorney representing him, objects to the search in respect to the items to be seized, at the end of the search, by alleging that those items are related to the professional relationship between the attorney and his client, then those items shall be placed in a separate envelope or a package and be sealed by the present individuals and, in the investigation phase, the judge of peace in criminal matters, or the judge or the Court in the prosecution phase, will render the necessary decision on this matter.”
Additionally, as per Art. 36 of Attorneyship Law No. 1136, “Attorneys are prohibited from disclosing information that has been entrusted to them, or that come to light in the course of performing their duties, both as attorneys, and as members of the Union of Bar Associations of Turkey and various bodies of bar associations.”
In accordance with the above-stated provisions of Attorneyship Law No. 1136 and Code No. 5271, whether or not there is an ultimate protection granted to the lawyer-client relationship is under discussion. Also, the distinction made between lawyer and ‘independent’ lawyer in the above-mentioned decisions is another issue to be discussed.
Conclusion
The Dow Decision is one of the most important decisions rendered by the Board on confidentiality of written communications between lawyer and client. Upon review of this decision, the Board’ perspective in terms of the legal protection that is granted to written communications between lawyer and client is clear. In this respect, based on the principle of confidentiality concerning written communications between lawyer and client, the Board sets forth the following conditions to be fulfilled: (i) the written communications must be made between client and independent lawyer who is not bound to the client by a relationship of employment, (ii) written communications must be made for the purposes, and in the interests, of the client’s rights of defence.
- Please see. http://www.rekabet.gov.tr/File/?path=ROOT%2f1%2fDocuments%2fGerek%C3%A7eli+Kurul+Karar%C4%B1%2f15-42-690-259.pdf (Access date: 21.04.2016)
- Please see. http://www.rekabet.gov.tr/File/?path=ROOT%2F1%2FDocuments%2FGerek%C3%A7eli+Kurul+Karar%C4%B1%2F14-29-596-262.pdf (Access date: 21.04.2016)
- Case 155/79 AM&S Europe Limited v. Commission of the European Communities, 18.5.1982, [1982] ECR 1575.
All rights of this article are reserved. This article may not be used, reproduced, copied, published, distributed, or otherwise disseminated without quotation or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm's written consent. Any content created without citing the resource or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm’s written consent is regularly tracked, and legal action will be taken in case of violation.
Other Contents
The startup ecosystem in Turkey has experienced notable growth in recent years. In the last quarter of 2023, 81 startups secured a combined investment of around 60 million dollars. While the number of investments remained consistent when comparing the third quarter periods of 2022-2023, there was a decrease...
Hub and Spoke cartel is a type of violation that is not clearly defined and regulated under Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition (“Law No. 4054”). Decisional practices of foreign competition authorities, particularly the UK Competition and Markets Authority’s decisions (“CMA”), are instructive concerning...
The Competition Board ("Board") made an addition to its line of decisions on resale price maintenance with its decision on Sunny Elektronik Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. ("Sunny") . In its decision, the Board thoroughly examined the allegations regarding Sunny's involvement in maintaining resale prices and restricting...
It is observed that the Competition Authority (“Authority”) has recently scrutinized various industries such as fast-moving consumer goods, labor market, pharmaceuticals, and cement. When the reasoned decisions of the Competition Board (“Board”) published in October are examined, it can be seen that the...
Jules Verne says, “Everything on earth has a limited lifespan, nothing that will exist forever can be created by human hands”. Perhaps change is the only constant concept in all our lives. Despite two major world wars and countless periods of crisis, humanity has been undergoing a great change and...
At the meeting of the Fédération Internationale de Football Association (“FIFA”) held on 16 December 2022, the FIFA Council approved the FIFA Football Agents Regulations (“FFAR”). In the FFAR, various amendments have been made, such as the introduction of a maximum service fee limit that football agents are...
Resale Price Maintenance (RPM) is still considered a hardcore restriction under the recently revised Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (VBER), which means that it cannot benefit from a statutory exemption under Article 101(1) TFEU, unlike certain other types of vertical agreements. However, it has been debated...
In competition law, it is important to accurately determine the concept of undertaking, especially in terms of mergers and acquisitions. Therefore, the concept of economic entity aims to reveal the economic units covered by the undertakings. The relationship between the concept of economic entity and family ties comes...
In these days when the Competition Board (“Board”) frequently imposes administrative fines for preventing on-site inspections and both the Competition Authority (“Authority”) and undertakings take legal and technical measures regarding on-site inspections, a striking development has occurred. In its decision...
Online advertising has become an important source for businesses for promoting products and services and meeting consumers, as a result of the rapid development of information technologies and increase in the use of internet. Delivering targeted messages to consumers at the right time through the digital...
Selective distribution systems refer to a type of distribution system in which suppliers commit to selling the contracted goods or services directly or indirectly to distributors selected based on specified criteria, while the distributors commit not to sell the said goods or services to unauthorized...
Fast-moving consumer goods is undoubtedly one of the sectors that the Competition Authority has been working most intensively since the COVID 19 pandemic. Among the most important developments of this period was the Sector Inquiry initiated on Fast Moving Consumer Goods (“FMCG”) Retailing...
In the decision of the Constitutional Court ("Constitutional Court" or "Court") dated 09.11.2022, numbered 2020/67 E. 2022/139 K. (the "Decision"), the annulment of certain articles of the Law Amending the Law on the Protection of Competition No. 4054 ("Law No. 7246") was requested...
In Turkish competition law, certain types of mergers and acquisitions are subject to Turkish Competition Board’s (“Board”) approval in order to gain legal validity. Pursuant to Article 7 of the Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition (“Law No. 4054”), the Board is competent to define mergers and acquisitions...
Recently, the Competition Board (the Board) had imposed administrative fines on banks and financial institutions for failing to respond to the request for information within the scope of a preliminary investigation.[i] The request for information that lays the groundwork for the administrative fine imposed by...
Amazon, a world-famous company, is an e-commerce company that operates the world’s largest online shopping platform. In the backstage, Amazon is a data-driven company whose retail decisions are mostly driven by automated systems, fueled by the relevant market data. That being said, Amazon has a dual...
The right to make on-site inspections is one of the Competition Board’s (“Board”) most important tools for revealing whether Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition (“Law No. 4054”) has been violated. The effective use of this authority is quite important in terms of obtaining fruitful results from...
“Harese” is an interesting Arabic word. There is a thorn that camels love very much in the desert. The camel eats the thorn with great greed. So much so that, its mouth bleeds as it eats, but it doesn't stop eating. The taste of the thorn is mixed with the salty taste of its own blood. This mixed taste drives the camel...
Turkey’s leading pay television service provider, Krea İçerik Hizmetleri ve Prodüksiyon A.Ş. (“Digiturk”), is frequently the subject of complaints made to the Competition Authority (“Authority”). In fact, the Competition Board (“Board”) issues a new decision about Digiturk almost every year. In these decisions...
The French Competition Authority (Autorité de la Concurrence), within the scope of the competition law proceeding initiated upon the complaint of Criteo SA (“Criteo”), accepted the commitments proposed by Meta Platforms Inc., Meta Platforms Ireland Ltd., and Facebook France...
While the scope of Competition Board’s (“Board”) power to conduct on-site inspections has increased with the introduction of Guidelines on Examination of Digital Data during On-site Inspections (“Guidelines”), nowadays the amount of monetary fines imposed on undertakings continue to...
The hub and spoke cartel, which is a relatively new type of violation in terms of Turkish competition law, is defined as the indirect exchange of information between two independent undertakings which are horizontal competitors on the supplier or retailer level, through another undertaking...
The settlement mechanism has only recently been introduced to Turkish competition law practice. It entered into force with the amendment made to the Law on the Protection of Competition (“Law”) numbered 4054 on 16.06.2020, and has been in effect for less than two years. In this relatively...
Due to their increasing share in the economy and rapid growth rate, e-marketplace platforms have come under the increasing scrutiny of the Turkish Competition Authority (“Authority”) as well as many competition authorities around the world...
Pursuant to the Amendment Communiqué Concerning the Mergers and Acquisitions Requiring the Competition Board’s Approval (“Amending Communiqué”) published in the Official Gazette dated March 4th, 2022 and numbered 31768, certain amendments have been introduced...
The Competition Board (“Board”) has recently published a reasoned decision in which it evaluated BSH Ev Aletleri Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş.’s (“BSH”) request for negative clearance or exemption with regard to its practice of prohibiting authorized dealers from making sales through online marketplaces...
Shahmaran, a Mesopotamian myth, is believed to take place in Tarsus. According to the myth, the shah of snakes is the immortal and omniscient "Shahmaran." Shahmaran is described as a beautiful woman living in her cave with her snakes...
During the COVID-19 pandemic, competitive concerns about the pricing behavior of chain markets, manufacturers, and wholesalers engaged in the retail trade of food and cleaning supplies led to an investigation by...
When the past decisions and the recent decisions of the Competition Board (“Board”) are examined, a significant increase can be observed in the number of decisions where the Board found hindrance or obstruction of on-site inspections. This situation shows that...
The European Commission began investigating the collusive behavior of Credit Suisse, UBS, Barclays, RBS, and HSBC in the Foreign Exchange (forex) spot trading market in 2019. With the recent press release dated 02.12.2021, the Commission announced that the case is now closed...
Digitalization, in particular, necessitates the rewriting of competition law rules. Competition law is at the center all questions regarding e-commerce and digital platforms. The aforementioned platforms, which have become prominent due to innovations in...