Monetary Limit for Legal Remedies in Administrative Jurisdiction
Introduction
In administrative cases concerning monetary matters, the right to appeal to ordinary legal remedies against the decisions of administrative and tax courts is subject to the condition that the dispute exceeds a certain monetary limit in the Turkish legal system. The monetary limit set for appeals to the Regional Administrative Courts and Court of Cassation is to be updated annually by the revaluation rate, however, the specific date on which the monetary limit will be applied for the appeal is not clearly regulated in the law.
The lack of clear and explicit regulation regarding which date’s monetary limit shall be considered for appeals and cassations has recently been the subject of two decisions by the Constitutional Court (“CC”), resulting in the annulment of some provisions of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 (“APL”).
This study examines the decision of the CC numbered 2023/36 E. 2023/142 K. and dated 26.07.2023 (“CC Decision-1”) , which resulted in the annulment of Article 46(1)(b) (“art. 46/1-b”) of the APL, as well as the decision of the AYM, numbered 2023/81 E. 2023/184 K. and dated 26.10.2023 (“CC Decision-2”) , which resulted in the annulment of the second sentence of Article 45(1) (“art.45/1-s.2”) and Annex-1 of the İYUK.
Monetary Limit for Resorting to Legal Remedy and its Application in Terms of Time
Art.45/1-s.2 of the APL regulates the monetary limits for appeals of the first instance court decisions, while art. 46/1-b regulates the monetary limits for cassation of the decisions subject to cassation. Art.45/1-s.2 stipulates that appeals cannot be lodged against the first instance courts’ decisions in tax cases, full remedy actions, and annulment cases against administrative acts that do not exceed a certain monetary limit; meanwhile while art. 46/1-b allows appeals to the Court of Cassations to be lodged against decisions in tax cases, full remedy actions, and annulment cases against administrative acts that exceed a certain monetary limit. Additionally, Annex 1 of the APL provides that these monetary limits should be increased annually by the revaluation rate.
However, these provisions and legislation do not contain explicit regulations regarding the impact of the monetary limit application on pending administrative cases. This situation creates a practical problem regarding when the monetary limits will be applied for appeals and cassations.
As a solution to this problem, the Council of State and regional administrative courts have developed the following jurisprudence: For the appeals to the regional administrative courts, the monetary limits are determined based on the date of the first-instance court’s decision; meanwhile, for the cassation, the date of the regional administrative courts’ decision is considered to determine whether the appeal or cassation route is available against the decisions in question.
However, as noted in legal doctrine, this approach may lead to other problems. This is because, unlike the wording of the Civil Procedure Code No. 6100 and Law No. 2576, the regulations in the APL allow for the application of monetary limits based on the date of the lawsuit. Furthermore, the impact of monetary limits in the appeal and cassation routes on pending administrative cases could result in sacrificing the principle of legal certainty for the principle of immediate application of procedural rules, which would be incompatible with the principle of the rule of law. Indeed, the change in monetary limits every year could undermine the principle of predictability; and in cases where two administrative lawsuits filed with the same monetary claim are concluded in different years, one of the decisions may fall below the updated monetary limit, which could also violate the principle of equality. These issues are discussed in the Constitutional Court decisions examined in this study.
CC Decision-1
Constitutional Court Decision-1 is a decision given following a request for the annulment of art. 46/1-b of the APL because the provision is unconstitutional, in a lawsuit filed for the refund of stamp duties, before the 2nd Tax Chamber of the Samsun Regional Administrative Court.
The CC stated that the contested rule imposes a limitation on the right to request the review of a judgment in cases falling below a certain monetary limit, emphasizing that any legislative regulation limiting the right to request the review of a judgment must be specific, accessible, and predictable to prevent arbitrariness. In its examination, the CC concluded that due to the annual updating of the monetary limit used to determine decisions subject to cassation, it is necessary for the specific date on which the monetary limit will be valid for resorting to the cassation route to be clearly and predictably determined in the law. However, the CC evaluated the lack of specific clarity and predictability in the law regarding this issue as not meeting the requirement of legality.
The CC also considered that the finalization of disputes that are not considered insignificant solely due to the value of the claim, without being subject to any review by the appellate court, violates the right to access to justice and the right to have the judgment reviewed by another judicial authority. According to the CC, the inability to review a court judgment due to the monetary limit regulation imposes an excessive burden on individuals and disrupts the balance in the exercise of the right of plaintiffs to request the review of the judgment, which is one of the purposes of art. 46/1-b of the APL aimed at reducing the workload of the Council of State.
The CC decided to annul Article 46/1-b of the APL because it violates the articles 13 and 36 of the Constitution. CC Decision-1 was published in the Official Gazette dated 13 October 2023 and numbered 32338. CC Decision-1 will come into effect nine months after its publication in the Official Gazette.
CC Decision-2
CC Decision-2 concerns the applications made by the 2ndTax Chamber of the Samsun Regional Administrative Court and the Istanbul 13th Administrative Court of First Instance regarding the annulment of the provisions of art.45/1-s.2 and Annex 1 of the APL, on the grounds of being unconstitutional, in a case concerning the cancellation of a payment order issued due to non-payment of a court-ordered judgment execution fee and in a case concerning an administrative fine imposed by the Social Security Institution.
In examining the contested provision, the CC, as in CC Decision-1, considered that any legislative regulation limiting the right to request the review of a judgment must be specific, accessible, and predictable to prevent arbitrariness. The CC also evaluated that due to the annual updating of the monetary limit, the lack of clear and predictable regulation in the law regarding which date's monetary limit would be valid for resorting to the appellate route constitutes a violation of the principle of legality.
The CC decided to annul art.45/1-s.2 of the APL, which regulates the monetary limit, and Annex-1 of the APL, which includes the rule for updating the monetary limit, because they are contrary to articles 13 and 36 of the Constitution. CC Decision-2 was published in the Official Gazette dated 21 December 2023 and numbered 32406. CC Decision-2 will come into effect nine months after its publication.
Conclusion
Based on the explanations provided above, the CC annulled both the provisions specifying the monetary limits for both the cassation and appeal routes and the provisions regulating the updating of these monetary limits in the APL. The nine-month periods prescribed for the entry into force of the CC Decisions have not yet elapsed.
When the grounds for annulment in the CC Decisions are examined, it may not be concluded that the monetary limits prescribed for the legal remedies are directly contrary to the Constitution. The CC has pointed out that it is not the monetary limit itself but the uncertainties and problems in its application that violate the Constitution. As of now, there has been no new legislative regulation based on the grounds for annulment stated in CC Decision-1 and CC Decision-2. However, if no regulation is made within these nine-month periods, the condition of the monetary limit for resorting to administrative jurisdiction may be deemed to have been eliminated. In this case, it is considered that the scope of the appellate application may expand, particularly.
- For the purposes of this study, the legal remedy to the Regional Administrative Courts shall be referred as “appeal” and, the legal remedy to the Court of Cassation shall be referred as “cassation” or “appeal to the Court of Cassation”, and the appellate court shall be used for Regional Administrative Courts
- Constitutional Court, 2023/36 E., 2023/142 K, T. 26.07.2023 (O.G.: 13.10.2023 /32338)
- Constitutional Court, 2023/81 E., 2023/184 K., T. 26.10.2023 (O.G.: 21.12.2023 /32406)
- For the decisions please see, Yılmaz, Serdar. “İdari Yargıda ‘Parasal Sınırlar’ın Konu Ve Zaman Bakımından Uygulanması Sorunu”. Ankara Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 72, sy. 4 (Şubat 2024): 1905-2006, p.1976-1977 footnote. 2021
- ibid p.1977-1978
All rights of this article are reserved. This article may not be used, reproduced, copied, published, distributed, or otherwise disseminated without quotation or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm's written consent. Any content created without citing the resource or Erdem & Erdem Law Firm’s written consent is regularly tracked, and legal action will be taken in case of violation.
Other Contents
The Resolution of the President dated 23.01.2024 and numbered 8123 on the Approval of the Amendment Protocol signed by the Exchange of Letters dated 6/12/2023 and 20/12/2023 between the Government of the Republic of Türkiye and the European Commission on the Amendment to the Financing Agreement...
The Resolution of the President dated 27.12.2023 and numbered 7996 on the Approval of the Annexed Financing Agreement for the Annual Action Programme for Türkiye for the Year 2022, Signed on behalf of the Republic of Türkiye on 30 November 2023, together with the accompanying Notes was...
The Law numbered 7478 on the Approval of the Ratification of the Air Services Agreement between the Government of the Republic of Türkiye and the Government of the Republic of Maldives entered into force through publication in the Official Gazette dated 29.11.2023 and numbered 32384...
The Resolution of the President dated 24.10.2023 and numbered 7731 on the Approval of the Protocol on Cooperation in the Field of Social Assistance and Social Services between the Government of the Republic of Türkiye and the Government of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus was published in the...
The Law on the Approval of the Ratification of the Intergovernmental Agreement on Dry Ports numbered 7459 was published in the Official Gazette dated 17.10.2023 and numbered 32342...
The Resolution of the President dated 14.09.2023 and numbered 7611 on the Approval of the Agreement signed between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Government of Hungary on 06/04/2023 on Cooperation in the Field of Sports was published in the Official Gazette dated 15.09.2023 and...
The concept of estate, which can be considered as the foundation of our inheritance law, refers to all the property, rights, and debts belonging to an individual after their death. Throughout history, humans have been buried with their cherished belongings based on religious beliefs, but over time, it has been observed...
The Resolution of the President dated 21.07.2023 and numbered 7393 on the Approval of the Memorandum of Understanding between the Government of the Republic of Türkiye and the Government of the People’s Democratic Republic of Algeria on Cooperation in the Field of Mining was published in the Official...
The Grant Agreement signed on 06.04.2023 between the Ministry of Treasury and Finance of Republic of Türkiye, Development and Investment Bank of Turkey (TKYB) and German Development Bank (KfW) was published in the Official Gazette dated 04.07.2023 and numbered 32238...
Inheritance contracts are contracts involving a testamentary disposition concluded by the legator, with her inheritor or a third party. A testamentary disposition is a legal transaction that includes the orders of the legator that she wishes to be carried out after her death. Testamentary disposition term is used in two...
The Resolution of the President dated 06.06.2023 and numbered 7302 on the Ratification of the Economic and Financial Cooperation Agreement between the Republic of Türkiye and the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus for 2023 was published in the Official Gazette dated 07.06.2023 and numbered 32214...
This study examines the decision ("Decision") of the Turkish Constitutional Court ("CC") dated 22.02.2023, published in the Official Gazette on April 28, 2023, which abolished the first sentence of Article 187 of the Turkish Civil Code numbered 4721 ("TCC"), which obliges a woman to take her husband's surname upon...
The Resolution on the Approval of the Annexed Amendment Letter Regarding the Separate Agreement on the Financing Agreement between the Ministry of National Education of the Republic of Turkey and the German Development Bank (KfW) on the Clean Energy and Energy Efficiency Measures Project...
The Resolution of the President dated 01.04.2023 and numbered 7025 on the Approval of the Protocol on the Accession of the Republic of Finland to the North Atlantic Treaty was published in the Official Gazette dated 02.04.2023 and numbered 32151...
The Resolution of the President dated 08.03.2023 and numbered 6913 on the Ratification of the Agreement between the Republic of Turkey and the European Union on the Participation of the Republic of Turkey in the Union Program on Cooperation in the Customs Area, ‘Customs’, effective from 1 January 2021...
The Resolution of the President dated 25.01.2023 and numbered 6728 on the Application of the Exemption in the Fourth Paragraph of the Provisional Article 14 of the Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 to the Foreign Currencies in the Balance Sheets of the Corporations as of 31.12.2022 was published in the Official...
The Resolution on the Approval of the Protocol between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Government of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus on the Deployment of Energy Transmission Lines of Geçitkale Airport (Resolution No: 6647) entered into force through publication in the...
The Resolution of the President dated 23.11.2022 and numbered 6416 on the Approval of the Economic and Financial Cooperation Agreement - Additional Agreement - signed between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Government of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus on...
The Resolution of the President dated 19.10.2022 and numbered 6238 on the Approval of the Memorandum of Understanding Between the Government of the Republic of Turkiye and the Government of the Federal Republic of Nigeria on Cooperation in the Field of Energy was published in the Official Gazette...
The Resolution of the President dated 26.09.2022 and numbered 6090 on the Approval of the Annexed Amendment Protocol signed by the Exchange of Letters dated 12.08.2022 and 31.08.2022 between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the European Commission on the Amendment to...
The Resolution of the President dated 15.09.2022 and numbered 6080 on the Approval of the Memorandum of Understanding About Implementation of the Multilateral Tax Program Between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development at...
Since social media has turned into a modern mass communication tool, the concepts of advertising and marketing have been brought to a new dimension. Influencers, who promote various products and services by "influencing" their audience through social media, are driving the next generation of...
The Resolution of the President dated 20.07.2022 and numbered 5801 on the Determination of the Default Interest Rate under the First Paragraph of Article 51 of the Law numbered 6183 on the Collection Procedure of Public Receivables as 2.5% to be Applied Separately for Each Month, was published...
Decision dated 27.06.2022 and numbered 5751 on the Ratification of the Fund Grant Agreement signed between Republic of Turkey Ministry of Labor and Social Security and International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, on 05.05.2022...
The Resolution of the President dated 23.05.2022 and numbered 5596 on the Ratification of the Economic and Financial Cooperation Agreement between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Government of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus was published in the Official Gazette dated...
The Resolution of the President dated 23.04.2022 and numbered 5520 on the Approval of the Agreement between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Government of the Republic of Cote D’Ivoire Concerning the Reciprocal Promotion and Protection of Investments...
In a decision dated 29.09.2021 with application number 2018/357 (“Decision”), the Constitutional Court decided by a large majority that the applicant's right to property was violated due to the fact that the immovables expropriated for the purpose of mass housing construction...
Pursuant to Art. 101 of the Turkish Civil Code (“CC”) No. 4721, foundations are an ensemble of assets that have legal personality, which comprises of sufficient assets and rights that are allocated by real and legal persons for a determined and perpetual objective. Foundations are legal persons that have “ideal...